Saroyan on Screen - Saroyan, Bean, and Mineo

Saroyan's appearances on Omnibus first used his plays written for the aborted Wonderful World of William Saroyan project in 1952. By 1955, those plays had either been used, including Ah, Sweet Mystery of Mrs. Murphy, The Abracadabra Kid, and A Christmas Tie, or set aside for various reasons. It does appear that he attempted to make one of those he set aside, A Picture in the Family Album, into an episode of Omnibus, but apparently abandoned the plan. He renamed at least one other and might have used elements of some in other plays, either produced or unproduced.
He began to write new works for Omnibus, and in 1955 produced 2 scripts that are incredibly interesting when taken together. Even more interesting is that both were very different, caused very different reactions, and reflected on so much of Soroyan's other work.
Omnibus episodes are difficult to come by these days, though some are available at least partially on YouTube. We have access to 7 of Soroyan's plays, though 2 only in select segments. The Paley Center has more episodes available for viewing in their locations, and several archives have individual episodes.
The four we will be looking at in this episode, and 2 others that will be looked at later, offer a strong glimpse of the variety of Soroyan's writing styles, tones, and moods.
The first we look at is The Best Year i
n the History of the Whole World.
When compared to his other plays, it's a bit lighter until the moment that it's not. We start with Paul, a clerk at a department store. He wants to make it there for good. He's only been there for 2 weeks and he wants to become a manager. His boss seems to want to give him the job. Thing is, Paul used to act, and apparently he used to be pretty good at it. But he got himself a job and it's a good job. His boss tasks him with playing the cooler, stopping potential returners of gifts from making the exchange. The first person to come in brings a trombone to return, and Paul, he works awfully hard to get him to change his mind and keep the trombone.
As time goes on, he deals with his mother, who is there trying to bring him celebratory champagne and caviar since it's the last day of 1955. She's a remarkably difficult character who wants nothing more than to spoil her son. She's followed by a woman trying to return a water pipe, which Paul treats at first as if it's a lamp. She recognizes him since she's seen him on stage and thought he was excellent. It wasn't his fault that the plays he's in were awful. And here is where we get things in the most Saroyanesque way possible.
Everyone wants young Paul to succeed. The customers, his mother, even his boss. This leads to some characters acting against their own best self-interest to help him succeed. There is a positivity to the piece that is impressive. It's such that even when Paul pulls away from living his dream for his new job, others work to make him move ahead in that one.
Paul is played with an incredible amount of energy by a young Orson Bean, whose career would last more than 50 years. The role was written rather broadly, and Bean throws himself into the piece hard. This is Saroyan writing for television as if it's still the stage, and watching that sort of writing today isn't as easy as it might have been for the viewers of the time. The anticipation for the play was high.
The Onlooker noted, Today's Omnibus is going to make another try with William Saroyan. If it's as successful as The Cool, Cool Moon was 2 years ago, it should be good. Today's Saroyan original will be a segment of the program. It is entitled The Year in the History of the Whole World(sic) and is a truly exuberant label. “
Sadly, the reviewers were not kind. Columnist Stan Anderson of See Hear, opined, “Omnibus is forever being accused of being highbrow, and such fare as this Saroyan play is by no means a way of proving the critics wrong, later adding, Bean made a magnificent try, but he could not get the playwright's message across. Paul Hartman, also engaged in this enterprise, Got so upset by the whole business that he flubbed about 50% of his lines.”
Even with the unfavorable reviews, the piece still has an important place in the history of television. It was one of the first appearances of the legendary Jean Stapleton, best known for her work on All in the Family.
Also in 1955 was a much more interesting, and far better received, piece. Omnibus had started a series of plays called Famous American Boyhoods that looked at the youth of significant Americans, and later added notable non-American William Shakespeare as well. These started in 1954 but were included throughout 1955. These vignettes focused mostly on famous military and religious figures, but Saroyan wrote a play that covered several vignettes from his youth in Fresno. The scenes included had also been previously written about in some of his books, and it could be seen as a companion piece to My Name Is Aram and the memoirs and autobiographies he had started writing in the early 1950s.
The opening of the segment is Saroyan himself doing the introduction: “Boyhood was pals: a brother, a cousin, a neighbor— Armenian, Greek, Italian, Slovenian, Portuguese, Mexican American, about 35 years ago, 1918 and 1919, in Fresno, California. This simple introduction sets the stage so incredibly well. It not only gives us the place and time, but the kinds of stories we'll be getting— stories of immigrant experiences, of youth and friendship.”
That quickly comes to sight on screen when actor Sal Mineo shows up playing a 10-year-old Saroyan.
Sal Mineo was a young actor who had already had several years experience, despite being only 15. He was just about ready for major international acclaim for his performance in Rebel Without a Cause opposite Natalie Wood and James Dean. He appears here first with his pal Buck, played by Pat DeSimone. That was his first television appearance, though he would only act for roughly a decade before retiring to become a firefighter. Though Buck is clearly a fictional character, he certainly seems to be an analog to Archie Minasian, Saroyan's cousin and best friend.
Saroyan's script for the play appears to have been written while traveling on a Union Pacific train on September 26th, 1955. He was returning to New York after a visit to California, though the timing is not quite in line with what we know about Saroyan's travels. The script was handwritten in the first draft, then typed up on hotel stationery when he arrived at the Great Northern Hotel in New York, where he had written The Time of Your Life as well.
The original version was nearly identical to the script version that was used by Omnibus, though there was one significant change early in the script process. Young Willy says that his teacher complained that there are too many Armenians. Buck asks Willy, how many are there? In the original form, Willy responds, “Well, the Saroyans, the Makarians, the Hagopians, the Krikorians.” These are significant Armenian families, all living within the Armeniatown community of Fresno. Saroyan crossed out those names and instead inserted the Saroyans, the Minasians, the Bagdasarians, the Garoghlanians” — all the names of Saroyan's extended family.
The play is several scenes from Saroyan's life, and the sense we get is of a young man who is experiencing a world that is imperfect, perhaps even prejudiced against him, but still has interactions that leaves both him and the viewer as hopeful for the future. Saroyan, in his role as narrator, ends the piece noting, “At its worst, the world is wonderful. At its best, it is unbelievable in its shabby grandeur.”
This might be Saroyan's finest writing for television, and it is so personal and more in line with the memoir work he would undertake leading to the book The Bicycle Rider in Beverly Hills. Critics reacted to this piece better than his previous work on Omnibus and gave strong reviews for the entire episode.
The San Francisco Chronicle noted, “Last Sunday, Omnibus once again proved the right to the title of Television's most distinguished program by presenting 2 of the most articulate men in the field of arts. The opening scenes of The California Boyhood of William Saroyan were handsomely acted and staged, with the gentleman himself narrating. The impressions of Fresno in the years 1916 to 1920 were made convincing through the efforts of 2 of the finest young actors I've seen on television, Sal Mineo and Pat DeSimone. The second half of the show was given over to Leonard Bernstein's personal tour through the jazz world, which traced the history of jazz without getting all fouled up with nostalgia in New Orleans. The discussion was backed by lively visual stunts and peppered with some excellent examples of today's jazz, which has become a sort of contemporary chamber music. It is very evident that each of these distinguished men was speaking about a subject which is dear to his heart. Mr. Bernstein on Jazz, and Mr. Saroyan on Mr. Saroyan.”
The California Boyhood is very interesting in that it is staged as a stage piece. While incorporating a more naturalistic form was not quite what television drama in this aspect was already doing, it did have an influence on later works you would see on places like NET, National Educational Television and PBS. The almost minimalist staging of stage productions started, largely, with Thornton Wilder's Our Town. The runaway success of that showed that a stripping away of scenery and props could actually make a more engaging theater piece. Here, that is used as we are not given a Fresno, but a stage that represents Fresno with elements that gently indicate small town America without specifying that it is Fresno. The beauty of the piece is that it takes both a nostalgic look at a time that was gaining a sort of quaint simplicity in the views of those living in 1950, while those watching today would see the piece as something of a turning point. Saroyan was looking inward and finding moments of his life that brought him where he ended up. The producers of Omnibus had captured lightning in a bottle with the famous Boyhood series and were looking out outwards from their position for fantastic new talent, which they found in both Sal Mineo and Pat de Simone. It is a wonderful document of a moment in time in television when maturity was just around the bend.
This is far from Soroyan's final play on Omnibus, and next time we'll be looking at 2 more: Vive! starring Bert Lahr, and A Christmas Tie starring Helen Hayes and Burgess Meredith. So I hope you'll stay tuned.
